What other Wilmette vendors will I need?

Wilmette Event Extras Wilmette Officiants Wilmette Bar Services & Beverages Wilmette Caterers Wilmette Beauty Professionals Wilmette Bands & DJs Wilmette Wedding Planners Wilmette Florists Wilmette Videographers Wilmette Photographers Wilmette Venues

The Best 10 Wedding Cake Bakeries in Wilmette, IL

51 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Wilmette, IL

Hidden gem

The Original Rainbow Cone

5.0

Starts at $1,350
Serves Wilmette, IL

The Original Rainbow Cone has been a staple in Chicago for over 95 years! We serve our signature combination of Chocolate, Strawberry, Palmer House, Pistachio and Orange Sherbet sliced and stacked on a cone. We also offer other flavors upon request. We offer on-site catering with our trucks for outdoor events, and our pop up ice cream social service for indoor events!

“My wife and I have always loved Rainbow Cone. Our first date was at their original Beverly location over 13 years ago, and it felt only fitting to have Rainbow Cone present at our wedding reception. From the beginning, John B. and his team were communicative, professional, and great to work with. On the day of the reception the RBC team showed up when they were supposed to and did an amazing job of providing quick and courteous scoop service to our 150 guests. They even went above and beyond and cleaned their area of the reception hall when our caterer dropped the ball and didn't do it themselves (please don't expect them to do this, but just to show they did an amazing job!) Plus, above all of that, the ice cream was just delicious, and initiated many folks into the Rainbow Cone fan club when they got their first taste. Overall, RBC provided a 10/10 experience that we'll always be thankful for and will never forget. We're fans for life. Thanks Rainbow Cone!”

Nick S., 4 years ago

Hidden gem

Sugargoat

5.0

Starts at $4
Serves Wilmette, IL

as stephanie izard's newest concept, sugargoat is your go-to bakery and special occasion sweets shop, and is a place where our team carries out goatland's tradition of showcasing the love of fun flavor combinations. enjoy your fondest food memories turned into tasty dessert experiences and continue to make more memories enjoying sweets with friends and family!

“My husband and I loved working with sugargoat for our wedding. As someone who doesn’t love cake but wanted the traditional experience of a cake cutting - I reached out to sugargoat to coordinate a tasting as I was intrigued by their adventurous flavors. We were able to set up a tasting quickly - the tasting consisted of their traditional flavors and a custom flavor that my husband and I came up with on our own - Peanut Butter, Jelly, Potato Chip. The bakery turned our flavor into the most delicious cupcake, so of course we included it as one of the layers in our wedding cake. I emailed inspiration photos of how I wanted our cake to look, and the team at sugargoat exceeded our expectations. Everyone was kind, and we loved communicating with Brennan. The team at sugargoat seemed genuinely excited about our wedding and our cake, it was nice to feel a personal connection with them vs. feeling like a number to them. Sadly on our wedding day, we did not have a piece of cake saved for her to eat, so I reached out to Brennan and they were able to make us a small cake of our custom flavor which we could eat on our Anniversary. 10/10”

Susie, 4 years ago

Quick responder

Bartleby's Homemade Ice Cream

5.0

Starts at $64
Serves Wilmette, IL
Offer

Our fresh, custom, elegantly decorated ice cream wedding cakes are like no other dessert option in Chicago! I have been creating ice cream cakes for decades and have been serving wedding customers in Chicago since 2019, first through Bartleby's Ice Cream Cakes online and since 2024 from the Bartleby's Homemade Ice Cream shop. With my many years of experience providing wedding cakes of all sizes, flavors, and designs and in all kinds of venues and weather, you can be sure that your Bartleby's cake will be beautiful, structurally sound, and delicious!

“My husband and I do not like traditional cakes for any celebration so we knew we wanted to do an ice cream cake for our wedding day. We have ordered Bartleby's ice cream cakes for numerous birthdays and other events and they are absolutely delicious. In addition to being delicious, I was able to work with Rachel to make this Celiac safe and free of any gluten cross contamination with a simple phone call. She made sure to make my gluten free wedding cake the first cake the day, to ensure all of the ice cream equipment was clean. She also works with another gluten free cookie company to add them to the ice cream cake as well. I can’t recommend Bartleby’s ice cream cake enough. Everyone will rave about your dessert and actually devour it!”

Laura, 2 years ago

Quick responder

Jitterbug Sweets

5.0

Starts at $100
Serves Wilmette, IL

Elevate your wedding celebration with Jitterbug Sweet's exquisite, hand-crafted chocolate-dipped confections. We specialize in creating visually stunning treats that taste as divine as they look. We have the option for custom flavors perfectly tailored to your unique love story.

“Always order candies on a quarterly basis and especially around holiday time for my work teams. Always receive the highest compliments on how great the sweets are!”

Dan B., 10 months ago

Hidden gem

Alliance Bakery

5.0

Starts at $175
Serves Wilmette, IL

We are a team of talented Pastry Chefs and Cake decorators. We provide desserts, occasion cakes and Weddings cakes to Hotels, resturants and catering companies. We create long lasting relationships with customers. It starts with your first order of cakes or desserts.

“Alliance bakery was very easy to work with. They were responsive, kind, and patient. The cake tasting was so fun and I love that we got to do it at home with the cake tasting kit. Everyone at the wedding loved the cake and it was beautiful!”

Carley H., a year ago

Hidden gem

Molly's Cupcakes

5.0

Starts at $3
Serves Wilmette, IL

Welcome to Molly's Cupcakes! Ms. Molly was my third-grade teacher. Whenever my classmates or I had a birthday, she would bake us cupcakes. She had her special recipe for chocolate and vanilla cupcakes. In honor of Molly and as a way to help our kids and community, a portion of our profits is donated directly to schools in our community. Every time you eat a cupcake or sip a latte, you help our kids. So eat up!

“So happy we decided to get our cake from Mollys cupcakes. We had our wedding in Chicago but live in NYC so the fact that Mollys had bakeries in both cities was a huge plus! They provided a free cake tasting of 6 different flavors, was very easy to work with and was priced very well compared to others I looked at. Their cupcakes/ cakes were DELICIOUS! Would highly recommend.”

Leyki D., 7 months ago

What's for Tea? Cake and Bakery

5.0

Starts at $40
Serves Wilmette, IL

Hello and welcome to What’s for Tea? Cake and Bakery! When I was designing where I wanted to go with this company, I knew I wanted things to be fresh and delicious, as well as beautiful. As the daughter of a British man, tea time has always been held in high regard, and the down to earth community around good food was always the most important thing. So here, I want to put my best efforts to help create something that tastes as memorable as it looks.

“Emily’s an amazing baker. She’s always willing to try new recipes, and her designs never fail. 100% recommend!”

Anouck, 8 months ago

Hidden gem

Windy City Cookies

5.0

Starts at $4 per serving
Serves Wilmette, IL

Hello future brides! I'm Audrey O'Shanna, owner and operator of Windy City Cookies. I specialize in custom sugar cookies. From favors to bachelorette parties, showers, and every event in-between. I love taking your vision and bringing it to life in the most delicious way! Fun fact about me, I took 1st place in the pastry division at "The Chicago's Best Baker" competition in 2018!

“Having sampled Audrey’s cookies before at other parties, I knew that she’d create something beautiful and delicious for our bridal shower. I was able to fill out a simple online form, and then did a quick phone consult to discuss our themes. Audrey delivered on several amazingly detailed designs, each individually wrapped, almost too pretty to eat! But these are definitely cookies that SHOULD be eaten, as they’re soft and delectable!”

Bridget & R., 4 years ago

Trending

Offbeat Macarons & Sweets

5.0

Starts at $4
Serves Wilmette, IL

We are a small, husband-and-wife bakery that specializes in boutique macarons, cakes, and pies. We're located in the Albany Park neighborhood of Chicago and serve the city as well as the surrounding Chicagoland area.

“I've ordered their macarons several times and they never disappoint! Pistachio and coconut are my favorite but honestly... I haven't tried one I didn't like. The cupcakes are dynamite too!”

Mark, a year ago

Trending

Candyality - Specialize in Candy Buffets

5.0

Starts at $8
Serves Wilmette, IL

We are a Black and Latina-owned business located in Lakeview. Our candy store has been beloved by Chicagoans for the last 16 years. Our store offers a vast selection of over 1,000 candies, gourmet chocolates and freshly made popcorn. Make your wedding or special event sweeter with unique party favors or a candy buffet from Candyality! We will work within your budget to create your desired party favors or candy buffet and will handle transportation and set-up. Contact us for a personalized quote today!

“I'm a planner and reached out to Candyality for one of my client's weddings - they absolutely killed it. The process was so smooth - they were very helpful and responsive - and everyone was thrilled on the wedding day.”

Jen G., a year ago

Black Dog Gelato

5.0

Serves Wilmette, IL

Black Dog Gelato is a local gelato shop that features Chef driven flavors. A nod to traditional style ice cream, Black Dog takes Chicago Style Gelato to a whole new level. We spin our gelato fresh everyday and are constantly changing flavors with the seasons. Unexpected and wonderful, BDG is truly a delight.

“We had a wonderful experience working with Black Dog Gelato! We had a cart at our wedding and our guests absolutely loved it. We were able to accommodate a variety of dietary needs and flavor preferences. It was perfect for our July wedding. The team at Black Dog was helpful and professional throughout the process and it was a pleasure working with them. I highly recommend Black Dog Gelato!”

Cara B., 2 years ago

Quick responder

A Little More Cookie

Starts at $60
Serves Wilmette, IL

A Little More Cookie specializes in hand-painted watercolor botanicals on iced shortbread cookies. Every cookie is it's own work of edible art! We use a second generation family recipe so your cookies will taste as good as they look!

Sugar Realm Bakery

Starts at $50
Serves Wilmette, IL

We are a small woman & LGBTQ+ owned business in Ravenswood, Chicago. We opened for business on February 1st, 2021. Everything you see here is handmade by us! It’s our mission to offer delicious cookies & pastries in flavors you can’t get anywhere else! We're proud to use the highest quality ingredients in all of our small-batch desserts, which are made fresh to order. We put lots of love and careful attention into each and every product we carry. We hope you enjoy our creations as much as we enjoy bringing them to you!!!

Schiller's Cookie Company

Starts at $60
Serves Wilmette, IL

Schiller's Cookie Company is a home bakery, offering delicious vanilla sugar cookies for events of all sizes. We are two sisters, with the passion and drive to bring edible art to our community. For over two years, we've been customizing vanilla sugar cookies for friends and family. We've taken the time to perfect our art and we're ready to share it with the world!

Quick responder

Dipsy Desserts

Serves Wilmette, IL

You know the song. Everyone screams for ice cream. Why not have an awesome, custom ice cream cart at your next event? With Dipsy Desserts, you can even include a custom note on every bar. Your guests will be able to choose from a ton of toppings to create their perfect ice cream treat. And for those who want something other than ice cream, we offer churros, waffles, fruit, and lots of other dippables! Have guests with food allergies or diet restrictions? We can accommodate them!

Armanda Bakery

Serves Wilmette, IL

ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,ugiljkm,

Hidden gem

Milk Bar

5.0

Starts at $300
Serves Wilmette, IL

Milk Bar is a sweet (and occasionally savory) shop that’s been turning familiar treats upside down and on their heads, shaking up the dessert scene since 2008. Bon Appetit magazine called us “one of the most exciting bakeries in the country.” But you can literally just call us Milk Bar. We’re not big on feeding the hype beast. But we’re super into feeding our flavorful treats to those who crave the unexpected.

“My husband and I have always loved Milk Bar cakes and they have made appearances throughout our relationship- at birthdays, our engagement, and just for fun. So it was a no-brainer that we wanted to have it as our wedding cake. We got married in Greenville, SC in October 2022 and it was so easy to arrange for them to be shipped down and arrive 2 days before the wedding. They arrived at our home and we dropped them off with our caters who placed the 6" cake on top of a 10" cake for the wedding day! It looked beautiful and our guests raved about how great it tasted. Months later, we still have guests asking where it was from! We also provided plastic to-go boxes for guests to take home the extras at the end of the night. We had 80 guests and purchased four 10" cakes and one 6" cake. Thank you Milk Bar for the easy and delicious process!”

Charity, 3 years ago

Quick responder

Delish Cakes

5.0

Starts at $30
Serves Wilmette, IL

Delish Cakes started in 2010 out of Alicia's family home. It quickly outgrew the house and a storefront was born shortly after! Delish Cakes will be 11 years old in August of 2021. Delish Cakes creates custom cakes and sweets for any occasion, and we love to make each order just as special as the clients who order them! Everything is created in small batches and made just for you. We do Cakes, cake pops, custom sugar cookies, sweet tables, cupcakes and more.

“I first found out about Delish Cakes at a wedding expo in Rosemont. I do not remember if the samples there were mini cup cakes or something else, but they were DELICIOUS! I reached out to Delish Cakes to do my wedding cake and loved that we we were able to do a tasting (you take a container home to sample different a few flavored cakes, frostings & fillings), although it was not free. Communication usually was not an issue. We were very happy with how our wedding cake turned out & are excited to have more for our 1st anniversary.”

Nicole L., a month ago

Sweet Temptations

5.0

Starts at $126
Serves Wilmette, IL

I am a home baker. Based in Bloomingdale IL . My business model is to get to know my clients to have a better understanding of what type of cakes they like. Then I sketch few cake options for them around their budget. This allows me to give a complete customized cake that represents their individuality. My clients mix and match cake flavors and fillings, or choose from the popular combinations I offer. I would love to work with you for your special day. You can contact me for more information!

“Sweet Temptations was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cake. Their communication throughout the entire process was easy, reliable, and smooth. The level of hardwork, effort, and dedication they put into crafting our stunning two-tiered cake with a delicious chocolate pistachio filling was evident in the final result. They even went the extra mile to drive down to our wedding venue to deliver the cake, and all of our guests raved about how incredible it looked and tasted. We couldn't have asked for a better bakery to help make our special day even sweeter.”

Sarah N., 2 months ago

Quick responder

Nadiya's Cupcakes

5.0

Starts at $640
Serves Wilmette, IL
Offer

Nadiya’s Cupcakes is a small business wedding cake bakery with an organic cake design style and a European-inspired cake flavor menu. Your wedding details are the most important ingredients in achieving your ultimate wedding cake vision, and you are part of every step to personalize it. Our cakes come tall and our specialty is buttercream; we do not use fondant. We love using fresh fruit and high quality raw ingredients to produce balanced flavors that have just the right amount of sweetness while retaining their natural, key-note taste; you and your family won't feel guilty going for a second slice, we promise.

“Nadiya created the most magical Harry Potter inspired wedding cake we could have dreamed of. From our first tasting to the final reveal, the entire experience felt thoughtful, creative and enchanting. She took every idea we shared and turned it into something far more beautiful than we imagined. The cake itself was pure magic. The hand painted Forbidden Forest, the white stag Patronus, the elegant gold detailing, the “Always” inscription and the Golden Snitch on top all came together so perfectly. It truly felt like a piece of the wizarding world brought to life in the most elegant way. On top of being stunning, the cake was completely gluten free for my allergy and still tasted absolutely incredible. Our guests were amazed that something so beautiful could also taste so good. People are still talking about it. Seeing the cake on our wedding day was a moment I will never forget. Nadiya’s talent, care and attention to detail made the entire experience unforgettable. We are so grateful for the magic she created and for giving us a cake that was meaningful, delicious and everything we hoped for. Thank you, Nadiya, for bringing our vision to life so perfectly.”

Crystal T., a month ago

Quick responder

My Cake Lady

5.0

Serves Wilmette, IL

With a passion for baking and a love for crafting unique treats, My Cakel Lady is here to help you celebrate your special moments with a custom cake. We work closely with our clients to bring their visions to life.

“Miriam is amazing! She was so easy to work with and made a delicious and beautiful cake! She brought our vision to life and the cake was one of the best I’ve ever had. The tasting process was so fun too, she delivered the flavors to our house! Can’t thank her enough! We will be back for all our cake needs!”

Lexi P., 7 months ago

Hidden gem

Bella Rosa Cannoli

5.0

Starts at $500
Serves Wilmette, IL

How do you make your wonderful event FAVOLOSO? Just add any of our Bella Rosa Cannoli services! Traditional and specialty fillings created by Chef Franco Contaldo with unique presentations that are sure to enhance your guests experience. We make them... just for you!

“We met Franco and his cannoli cart at a farmer's market and were immediately impressed with the quality of his products--which kept us coming back week after week--and the friendliness of his whole team. Each cannoli is handmade with care. We loved Franco and the cannolis so much that we replaced a traditional wedding cake with his mobile cannoli cart and couldn't have been happier with the way it added to our wedding. The guests couldn't get enough, and using two cannolis for our "cake cutting" was unforgettable. Reasonably priced, reliable, delicious, all served with a smile and Italian charm. Don't walk, run to get yours!”

Lori W., a month ago

Waffle groove

5.0

Starts at $375
Serves Wilmette, IL

Waffle Groove is a pop-up dessert cart specializing in delightful treats that can elevate any event. We provide our unique offerings for your upcoming parties, weddings, and celebrations. Our menu includes: - Waffles on a stick, perfect for a fun and interactive dessert experience - Mini pancakes, ideal for a sweet bite anytime - Refreshing snow cones, great for cooling down during outdoor events - Authentic Irani chai, a favorite that pairs beautifully with any gathering - Dubai strawberry cups, a delicious and beautifully presented treat

“Waffle Groove was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding! From the moment we first reached out, their communication was professional, happy, and delightful. The quality of their work and the value they provided was truly top-notch - their waffles were crisp on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside, and the toppings were fresh and beautifully presented. The setup they provided added such a fun, inviting touch to our event. They were punctual, professional, and made sure every guest left smiling (and full!). Waffle Groove truly made our event delicious and we highly recommend them for weddings, fairs, or any event that needs a delicious highlight.”

Kauser, a month ago

Quick responder

Ethalle's Cakes and Bakes

5.0

Starts at $360
Serves Wilmette, IL

Welcome to my page! My name is Ethalle, and I always loved to watch baking and cooking competitions. There was always something incredible about seeing how much technical skills, ingenuity, and creativity it takes to create something so beautiful and delicious. It's my absolute pleasure to design your wedding cake and desserts to make your dreams a reality!

“Ethalle's Cakes and Bakes was the absolute sweetest to work with for my wedding. I gave her my wedding mood board and she made sure all the cakes and bakes she created matched the theme perfectly! I was especially excited about the rice crispies and cake pops, but by the time I had a moment to grab some, they were all gone! Everyone kept raving about how delicious they were, and Ethalle even gave me a rice crispy treat afterwards (with my wedding colors!) so that I didn't miss out. Tasty custom sweets at a great value - I highly recommend Ethalle's Cakes and Bakes!”

Arletta, 3 months ago

Trending

Milette's Cakes

5.0

Starts at $60
Serves Wilmette, IL

At Milette's Cakes, we bring over a decade of experience in crafting elegant cakes, specializing in stunning wedding cakes that make your special day unforgettable. As the proud winner of Cupcake Wars in 2012, our passion for dessert artistry shines in every creation. We collaborate closely with each couple, starting with a personalized cake tasting to discuss traditions and preferences. Our keen eye for detail and commitment to using the finest ingredients ensure that each cake looks spectacular and tastes amazing. Trust Milette's Cakes to add a touch of magic to your wedding with a masterpiece you and your guests will cherish for years!

“From start to finish everything was great. My cake was super moist and delicious. The cake was bigger than what I was expecting but my husband was happy not to get a sliver piece of cake.”

Sheila O., a year ago

Quick responder

Sweeney Girl Sweets

5.0

Starts at $3
Serves Wilmette, IL

Baking is therapeutic for me. Having baked with my grandparents as a child, I've baked all my life and I really truly enjoy seeing smiles when people try my made-from-scratch sweets. My fun bubbly personality has transferred over into my business brand and products.

“Such a great addition to our perfect day! The cupcakes we ordered were incredible and all of our guests loved them! Customer service was excellent from trying the cupcakes, Molly brought them personally to our home and trialed new flavors for us. The Oreo was a hit! Delivery was seamless and I as the bride didn’t have to stress at all. Would absolutely recommend for your big event or even just treats to have!”

Mackenzie S., 5 months ago

Trending

Let Them Eat Cakes

5.0

Starts at $48
Serves Wilmette, IL

Let Them Eat Cakes aspires to make your sweets as unique and memorable as your wedding day. I believe that your dessert is a way to tie your whole wedding day together and treat yourself and all your guests to a dessert that you and your partner find most sweet. Whether you want an elegant tiered wedding cake or a pastry table, or you and your partner love pies and enjoy a pie bar, Let Them Eat Cakes will make a dessert that perfectly reflects your love story and wedding day.

“Ava was amazing to work with and made the entire process fun and easy for us. The cake and cookies looked and tasted excellent. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience on our big day!”

Jake H., 20 days ago

The Quintessential Cake

5.0

Starts at $500
Serves Wilmette, IL

The Quintessential Cake is a premier cake studio, specializing in designer wedding cakes. Each cake is individually designed to reflect our clients’ unique style and taste, ensuring it perfectly compliments the aesthetic of the event and is ultimately a one of a kind centerpiece. Our commitment to using only the finest and freshest ingredients means that our handmade cakes are as delicious as they are stunning. We can provide you with the cake of your dreams….your quintessential cake. Please visit our website for more information or to submit an enquiry.

“Stunning cakes, almost too beautiful to eat.... almost ;)”

Joy, 5 years ago

BakerBitesCo

5.0

Starts at $200
Serves Wilmette, IL

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

“Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!”

Linda, 5 years ago

The Bun Bar

Starts at $7
Serves Wilmette, IL

Hello and Welcome to The Bun Bar! I’m Savannah, the creator, and brains behind the buns. Before you order our sweet and savory buns for your next event, let me tell you a bit about myself. I was born and raised in the Northwest suburbs of Chicago and a recent grad of the University of Iowa. My love for all things food doesn’t have a starting point, it has always been part of my life. I started The Bun Bar in hopes of sharing my love of baking with others. Nothing brings me more joy than seeing happy customers and bringing people together to enjoy a sweet treat!